Welcome to Nico’s Cajun Island
Nico’s Cajun Island, located in Reynoldsburg, OH, is an eclectic New Orleans-style restaurant offering authentic Cajun/Creole cuisine. Known for their popular dishes like the Cajun chicken platter and blackened chicken with bowtie pasta, this spot is a go-to for flavorful meals. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes, making it perfect for sharing. While some prefer takeout due to the bustling noise inside, the outdoor seating provides a quieter alternative. With a diverse menu including seafood pasta, gator bites, and Rasta pasta, Nico’s Cajun Island is a hidden gem worth discovering for a taste of the Bayou in Ohio.
Nico’s Cajun Island: Reviews & Ratings
Cajun chicken platter is unlike anything else I've eaten. Whole family loves it. I love everything about this place.
Had my first visit and my meal (crawdad etouffee) that was made to order and it was very good. Not really spicy (at least to me) but it's easy to rectify that. The website is very out of date in terms of pricing but was justified by the huge portion. It was easily enough for 2. I have included a photo of the current menu and pricing. Plan to take your meal to go. I had hoped to dine in but they were absolutely BLASTING a regular radio station, including commercials, political ads, etc., over a large speaker. There were also 2 tv's, on different stations, playing at a low volume. The overall noise was overwhelming and uncomfortable. I have taken a star off the rating because of this. I sat outside next to a busy road instead because it was much quieter.
Some people just come here for the blackened chicken, bowtie pasta dish. Those some people are me. The chicken, bowtie pasta dish is probably one of the best pasta dishes I have ever tasted. I don't live on this side of town but anytime I'm craving it I happily drive across town yo grab it. Never disappoints!
This place is in the on a major street but can be hard to find if you aren't looking. It's almost like an oasis in the middle of a desert. I would recommend the blackened chicken with the bowtie pasta and add some bourbon sauce. The Rasta pasta is also really good, chicken and steak is my go to. They also have a really good seafood pasta dish and their wings are
First time trying Cajun Island Blackened Chicken with Bow-tie pasta was recommended as a bestseller. This is a very eclectic New Orleans-style restaurant serving authentic style food, they even have gator bites which I didn't try this time. Most patrons were doing carryout and there was a wait for those that had a large order. Next time I will try one or all of the following Seafood pasta shrimp, Surimi crab in lobster sauce Muddy rice with shrimp and sausage Blackened chicken alfredo Black pepper pasta with shrimp and sausage Cajun Island 1765 Brice Rd Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
The blackened Cajun pasta is AMAZING. We order the family portion and it feeds sooooooo many people. This is often our go-to for family parties!
Location
-
1765 Brice Rd Reynoldsburg, OH 43068 Hotline: (614) 866-6300
Nico’s Cajun Island is a hidden gem in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, serving up authentic Cajun and Creole cuisine that will transport your taste buds straight to the bayou. With a menu full of flavorful options like the Cajun chicken platter, crawdad etouffee, blackened chicken bowtie pasta, and Rasta pasta, this restaurant is a must-visit for food lovers looking to spice up their meals.
Customers rave about the generous portion sizes and the mouth-watering flavors of each dish. The blackened Cajun pasta is a favorite among many, offering a deliciously unique blend of spices and ingredients that will leave you craving more. The restaurant also offers vegetarian options, catering services, and a full bar for those looking to enjoy a drink with their meal.
Despite some noise complaints from customers, the overall dining experience at Nico's Cajun Island is highly praised for its quality food and welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're dining in or taking your meal to go, this restaurant is sure to satisfy your cravings for bold and delicious Cajun flavors. Visit Nico’s Cajun Island today and experience a taste of Louisiana right in Ohio.
